2

次の2つのSELECTステートメントの違いが（視覚的に）最適であることを知りたいです。

SELECT P.* and X.* 
FROM Table1 P
LEFT OUTER JOIN 
    Table2 X ON
    and  p.B=x.B
and  p.C=x.C
and  p.F=x.F
and  p.D=x.D 

WHERE X.F= 1 and X.E=4

と

SELECT P.* and X.* 
FROM Table1 P
LEFT OUTER JOIN 
    (SELECT * FROM Table2 WHERE X.F= 1 and X.E =4) X
    and  p.B=x.B
and  p.C=x.C
and  p.F=x.F
and  p.D=x.D

同じ数の行を返しません。Table1には5000行があり、Table2にも5000行があるとします。最初のselect joinステートメントは最大40000行（作業中のクエリに固有）を返し、where句が適用されると約2000行を返します。

2番目のselect joinステートメントは5000行（元の番号）を返します。これは私が欲しい番号です。

しかし、なぜこれが起こっているのか理解できないようです。私の知識と結合の視覚化は少し弱いです。

サンプルデータ：一時テーブルの名前を変更してください。同じです。また、適切な列名を指定できませんでしたが、一致させたい列を示すようにコードを編集しました。これが表1です。

    SELECT * INTO #tmp_GridResults_1
FROM (
SELECT N'0' AS [ID], N'P' AS [B], N'1' AS [C], N'0' AS [D], N'1' AS [E], N'1' AS [F] UNION ALL
SELECT N'0' AS [ID], N'P' AS [B], N'1' AS [C], N'0' AS [D], N'1' AS [E], N'2' AS [F] UNION ALL
SELECT N'0' AS [ID], N'P' AS [B], N'1' AS [C], N'1' AS [D], N'1' AS [E], N'1' AS [F] UNION ALL
SELECT N'0' AS [ID], N'P' AS [B], N'1' AS [C], N'1' AS [D], N'1' AS [E], N'2' AS [F] UNION ALL
SELECT N'0' AS [ID], N'P' AS [B], N'2' AS [C], N'0' AS [D], N'1' AS [E], N'1' AS [F] UNION ALL
SELECT N'0' AS [ID], N'P' AS [B], N'2' AS [C], N'0' AS [D], N'1' AS [E], N'2' AS [F] UNION ALL
SELECT N'0' AS [ID], N'P' AS [B], N'2' AS [C], N'1' AS [D], N'1' AS [E], N'1' AS [F] UNION ALL
SELECT N'0' AS [ID], N'P' AS [B], N'2' AS [C], N'1' AS [D], N'1' AS [E], N'2' AS [F] ) t;
SELECT [ID], [B], [C], [D], [E], [F]
FROM #tmp_GridResults_1

DROP TABLE #tmp_GridResults_1
GO

表2は次のとおりです。---------------＃tmp_GridResults_1 ---------------

SELECT * INTO #tmp_GridResults_1
FROM (
SELECT N'0' AS [ID], N'P' AS [B], N'1' AS [C], N'0' AS [D], N'0' AS [E], N'1' AS [F] UNION ALL
SELECT N'0' AS [ID], N'P' AS [B], N'2' AS [C], N'0' AS [D], N'0' AS [E], N'1' AS [F] UNION ALL
SELECT N'0' AS [ID], N'P' AS [B], N'1' AS [C], N'0' AS [D], N'0' AS [E], N'2' AS [F] UNION ALL
SELECT N'0' AS [ID], N'P' AS [B], N'2' AS [C], N'0' AS [D], N'0' AS [E], N'2' AS [F] UNION ALL
SELECT N'0' AS [ID], N'P' AS [B], N'1' AS [C], N'1' AS [D], N'0' AS [E], N'1' AS [F] UNION ALL
SELECT N'0' AS [ID], N'P' AS [B], N'2' AS [C], N'1' AS [D], N'0' AS [E], N'1' AS [F] UNION ALL
SELECT N'0' AS [ID], N'P' AS [B], N'1' AS [C], N'1' AS [D], N'0' AS [E], N'2' AS [F] UNION ALL
SELECT N'0' AS [ID], N'P' AS [B], N'2' AS [C], N'1' AS [D], N'0' AS [E], N'2' AS [F] UNION ALL
SELECT N'0' AS [ID], N'P' AS [B], N'1' AS [C], N'-1' AS [D], N'1' AS [E], N'1' AS [F] UNION ALL
SELECT N'0' AS [ID], N'P' AS [B], N'2' AS [C], N'-1' AS [D], N'1' AS [E], N'1' AS [F] UNION ALL
SELECT N'0' AS [ID], N'P' AS [B], N'1' AS [C], N'-1' AS [D], N'1' AS [E], N'2' AS [F] UNION ALL
SELECT N'0' AS [ID], N'P' AS [B], N'2' AS [C], N'-1' AS [D], N'1' AS [E], N'2' AS [F] UNION ALL
SELECT N'0' AS [ID], N'P' AS [B], N'1' AS [C], N'0' AS [D], N'1' AS [E], N'1' AS [F] UNION ALL
SELECT N'0' AS [ID], N'P' AS [B], N'2' AS [C], N'0' AS [D], N'1' AS [E], N'1' AS [F] UNION ALL
SELECT N'0' AS [ID], N'P' AS [B], N'1' AS [C], N'0' AS [D], N'1' AS [E], N'2' AS [F] UNION ALL
SELECT N'0' AS [ID], N'P' AS [B], N'2' AS [C], N'0' AS [D], N'1' AS [E], N'2' AS [F] UNION ALL
SELECT N'0' AS [ID], N'P' AS [B], N'1' AS [C], N'1' AS [D], N'1' AS [E], N'1' AS [F] UNION ALL
SELECT N'0' AS [ID], N'P' AS [B], N'2' AS [C], N'1' AS [D], N'1' AS [E], N'1' AS [F] UNION ALL
SELECT N'0' AS [ID], N'P' AS [B], N'1' AS [C], N'1' AS [D], N'1' AS [E], N'2' AS [F] UNION ALL
SELECT N'0' AS [ID], N'P' AS [B], N'2' AS [C], N'1' AS [D], N'1' AS [E], N'2' AS [F] UNION ALL
SELECT N'0' AS [ID], N'P' AS [B], N'1' AS [C], N'-1' AS [D], N'2' AS [E], N'1' AS [F] UNION ALL
SELECT N'0' AS [ID], N'P' AS [B], N'2' AS [C], N'-1' AS [D], N'2' AS [E], N'1' AS [F] UNION ALL
SELECT N'0' AS [ID], N'P' AS [B], N'1' AS [C], N'-1' AS [D], N'2' AS [E], N'2' AS [F] UNION ALL
SELECT N'0' AS [ID], N'P' AS [B], N'2' AS [C], N'-1' AS [D], N'2' AS [E], N'2' AS [F] UNION ALL
SELECT N'0' AS [ID], N'P' AS [B], N'1' AS [C], N'0' AS [D], N'2' AS [E], N'1' AS [F] UNION ALL
SELECT N'0' AS [ID], N'P' AS [B], N'2' AS [C], N'0' AS [D], N'2' AS [E], N'1' AS [F] UNION ALL
SELECT N'0' AS [ID], N'P' AS [B], N'1' AS [C], N'0' AS [D], N'2' AS [E], N'2' AS [F] UNION ALL
SELECT N'0' AS [ID], N'P' AS [B], N'2' AS [C], N'0' AS [D], N'2' AS [E], N'2' AS [F] UNION ALL
SELECT N'0' AS [ID], N'P' AS [B], N'1' AS [C], N'1' AS [D], N'2' AS [E], N'1' AS [F] UNION ALL
SELECT N'0' AS [ID], N'P' AS [B], N'2' AS [C], N'1' AS [D], N'2' AS [E], N'1' AS [F] UNION ALL
SELECT N'0' AS [ID], N'P' AS [B], N'1' AS [C], N'1' AS [D], N'2' AS [E], N'2' AS [F] UNION ALL
SELECT N'0' AS [ID], N'P' AS [B], N'2' AS [C], N'1' AS [D], N'2' AS [E], N'2' AS [F] UNION ALL
SELECT N'0' AS [ID], N'P' AS [B], N'1' AS [C], N'-1' AS [D], N'3' AS [E], N'1' AS [F] UNION ALL
SELECT N'0' AS [ID], N'P' AS [B], N'2' AS [C], N'-1' AS [D], N'3' AS [E], N'1' AS [F] UNION ALL
SELECT N'0' AS [ID], N'P' AS [B], N'1' AS [C], N'-1' AS [D], N'3' AS [E], N'2' AS [F] UNION ALL
SELECT N'0' AS [ID], N'P' AS [B], N'2' AS [C], N'-1' AS [D], N'3' AS [E], N'2' AS [F] UNION ALL
SELECT N'0' AS [ID], N'P' AS [B], N'1' AS [C], N'0' AS [D], N'3' AS [E], N'1' AS [F] UNION ALL
SELECT N'0' AS [ID], N'P' AS [B], N'2' AS [C], N'0' AS [D], N'3' AS [E], N'1' AS [F] UNION ALL
SELECT N'0' AS [ID], N'P' AS [B], N'1' AS [C], N'0' AS [D], N'3' AS [E], N'2' AS [F] UNION ALL
SELECT N'0' AS [ID], N'P' AS [B], N'2' AS [C], N'0' AS [D], N'3' AS [E], N'2' AS [F] UNION ALL
SELECT N'0' AS [ID], N'P' AS [B], N'1' AS [C], N'1' AS [D], N'3' AS [E], N'1' AS [F] UNION ALL
SELECT N'0' AS [ID], N'P' AS [B], N'2' AS [C], N'1' AS [D], N'3' AS [E], N'1' AS [F] UNION ALL
SELECT N'0' AS [ID], N'P' AS [B], N'1' AS [C], N'1' AS [D], N'3' AS [E], N'2' AS [F] UNION ALL
SELECT N'0' AS [ID], N'P' AS [B], N'2' AS [C], N'1' AS [D], N'3' AS [E], N'2' AS [F] UNION ALL
SELECT N'0' AS [ID], N'P' AS [B], N'1' AS [C], N'-1' AS [D], N'4' AS [E], N'1' AS [F] UNION ALL
SELECT N'0' AS [ID], N'P' AS [B], N'2' AS [C], N'-1' AS [D], N'4' AS [E], N'1' AS [F] UNION ALL
SELECT N'0' AS [ID], N'P' AS [B], N'1' AS [C], N'-1' AS [D], N'4' AS [E], N'2' AS [F] UNION ALL
SELECT N'0' AS [ID], N'P' AS [B], N'2' AS [C], N'-1' AS [D], N'4' AS [E], N'2' AS [F] UNION ALL
SELECT N'0' AS [ID], N'P' AS [B], N'1' AS [C], N'0' AS [D], N'4' AS [E], N'1' AS [F] UNION ALL
SELECT N'0' AS [ID], N'P' AS [B], N'2' AS [C], N'0' AS [D], N'4' AS [E], N'1' AS [F] UNION ALL
SELECT N'0' AS [ID], N'P' AS [B], N'1' AS [C], N'0' AS [D], N'4' AS [E], N'2' AS [F] UNION ALL
SELECT N'0' AS [ID], N'P' AS [B], N'2' AS [C], N'0' AS [D], N'4' AS [E], N'2' AS [F] UNION ALL
SELECT N'0' AS [ID], N'P' AS [B], N'1' AS [C], N'1' AS [D], N'4' AS [E], N'1' AS [F] UNION ALL
SELECT N'0' AS [ID], N'P' AS [B], N'2' AS [C], N'1' AS [D], N'4' AS [E], N'1' AS [F] UNION ALL
SELECT N'0' AS [ID], N'P' AS [B], N'1' AS [C], N'1' AS [D], N'4' AS [E], N'2' AS [F] UNION ALL
SELECT N'0' AS [ID], N'P' AS [B], N'2' AS [C], N'1' AS [D], N'4' AS [E], N'2' AS [F] UNION ALL
SELECT N'0' AS [ID], N'P' AS [B], N'1' AS [C], N'-1' AS [D], N'98' AS [E], N'1' AS [F] UNION ALL
SELECT N'0' AS [ID], N'P' AS [B], N'2' AS [C], N'-1' AS [D], N'98' AS [E], N'1' AS [F] UNION ALL
SELECT N'0' AS [ID], N'P' AS [B], N'1' AS [C], N'-1' AS [D], N'98' AS [E], N'2' AS [F] UNION ALL
SELECT N'0' AS [ID], N'P' AS [B], N'2' AS [C], N'-1' AS [D], N'98' AS [E], N'2' AS [F] UNION ALL
SELECT N'0' AS [ID], N'P' AS [B], N'1' AS [C], N'0' AS [D], N'98' AS [E], N'1' AS [F] UNION ALL
SELECT N'0' AS [ID], N'P' AS [B], N'2' AS [C], N'0' AS [D], N'98' AS [E], N'1' AS [F] UNION ALL
SELECT N'0' AS [ID], N'P' AS [B], N'1' AS [C], N'0' AS [D], N'98' AS [E], N'2' AS [F] UNION ALL
SELECT N'0' AS [ID], N'P' AS [B], N'2' AS [C], N'0' AS [D], N'98' AS [E], N'2' AS [F] UNION ALL
SELECT N'0' AS [ID], N'P' AS [B], N'1' AS [C], N'1' AS [D], N'98' AS [E], N'1' AS [F] UNION ALL
SELECT N'0' AS [ID], N'P' AS [B], N'2' AS [C], N'1' AS [D], N'98' AS [E], N'1' AS [F] UNION ALL
SELECT N'0' AS [ID], N'P' AS [B], N'1' AS [C], N'1' AS [D], N'98' AS [E], N'2' AS [F] UNION ALL
SELECT N'0' AS [ID], N'P' AS [B], N'2' AS [C], N'1' AS [D], N'98' AS [E], N'2' AS [F] ) t;
SELECT [ID], [B], [C], [D], [E], [F]
FROM #tmp_GridResults_1

DROP TABLE #tmp_GridResults_1
GO
4

1 に答える 1

1

WHERE 句にフィルター基準を配置し、その基準が結合の「外部」テーブルに対する条件を指示する場合、実質的にその外部結合を内部結合に変換します。外部結合テーブルに対するフィルター条件は、where ではなく結合に属します。

このバージョンでは何行生成されますか?

SELECT P.*, X.* 
FROM Table1 P
LEFT OUTER JOIN Table2 X
    on P.Id = X.id 
    and P.name = X.name 
    and P.age = X.age 
    AND X.bar = 1 
    and X.name ='value';

理論的には、これにより、最初のステートメントの行数以上、2 番目のステートメントの行数が得られるはずです。

これを既存の結果と比較したい場合は、次のことができます。

SELECT P.*, X.* 
FROM Table1 P
LEFT OUTER JOIN Table2 X
    on P.Id = X.id 
    and P.name = X.name 
    and P.age = X.age 
    AND X.bar = 1 
    and X.name ='value'
EXCEPT
SELECT P.* and X.*
FROM Table1 P
LEFT OUTER JOIN 
    (SELECT * FROM Table2 WHERE X.bar = 1 and X.name ='value') X
    on P.Id = X.id 
    and P.name = X.name 
    and P.age = X.age;

結果が得られない場合、それらは同じです。逆の方法でもできます。

SELECT P.*, X.* 
FROM Table1 P
LEFT OUTER JOIN Table2 X
    on P.Id = X.id 
    and P.name = X.name 
    and P.age = X.age 
    AND X.bar = 1 
    and X.name ='value'
INTERSECT
SELECT P.* and X.*
FROM Table1 P
LEFT OUTER JOIN 
    (SELECT * FROM Table2 WHERE X.bar = 1 and X.name ='value') X
    on P.Id = X.id 
    and P.name = X.name 
    and P.age = X.age;

5000 行を取得した場合 (または、後者のクエリ自体の正確な行数が何であれ)、結果セットは同じです。

于 2012-05-02T16:11:21.433 に答える